Plans for a caravan and glamping site in Menstrie have prompted a mix of responses from the local community, with over 20 formal objections submitted. Concerns raised by residents focus on potential environmental impacts, safety, and how the development might influence the area.
The proposed project, submitted by John Foy of Gretna, features 10 caravan pitches, five glamping pods, a café, and a toilet and office building on a green space along Tullibody Road. The application is currently under review by Clackmannanshire Council’s Planning Department.
The site’s location on an active travel path used by pedestrians and cyclists has been a focal point of discussion. Residents, including Calum Macleod, have highlighted the importance of this route for local walkers and cyclists.
Safety concerns have also been noted, particularly due to the nearby humpback bridge on Tullibody Road. Critics have pointed out the limited visibility and potential hazards of increased traffic in the area, emphasizing the need for careful consideration of vulnerable road users, such as children and individuals with mobility aids.
According to a report by the Alloa Advertiser, the proposed development’s impact on local wildlife is another topic under scrutiny. Some residents have noted that the area is home to species such as bats and owls, with bats being protected under the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017.
While some residents have expressed doubts about the project’s necessity, citing existing accommodation options and questions about demand, the developer has emphasized the potential economic and tourism benefits.
Provisions for cycling infrastructure, biodiversity restoration, and nature-sensitive designs have been included in the plans to address environmental concerns.
The council validated the application on October 17, and a decision is anticipated in the coming weeks.
This scenario underscores the complexities of developing outdoor hospitality accommodations, especially in areas with active community engagement and environmental considerations.
For industry professionals, it serves as a case study in balancing local concerns with the economic and tourism opportunities such projects can bring.
