The Perth and Kinross Council recently refused a planning application by Verdant Leisure 2 Ltd for the expansion of Erigmore Leisure Park in Birnam. The proposed plan, which included adding 76 lodges to the existing 157 caravans, was met with significant opposition from the local community and raised environmental concerns, as reported by Daily Record.
The application faced 99 objections from 91 households, reflecting widespread community concern. Residents expressed apprehensions about the project’s visual impact, its potential to alter the character of the area, and the effects on popular local walking paths.
A major factor in the council’s decision was the impact on the scenic beauty of the region, particularly the public path along the south bank of the Tay. Despite proposed landscaping efforts, the council deemed the visual impact significant and potentially detrimental to the area’s natural appeal.
Peter Shannon, representing the planning interests of the holiday park, argued that the economic benefits of the expansion, including job creation and increased tourism, were not adequately considered in the council’s decision-making process, according to a report by the Daily Record .
Sean Panton, the planning officer, acknowledged the possibility of expanding the site but emphasized that the current proposal’s design and layout were not suitable. The scale of the proposed development and its deviation from the existing character of the area were major sticking points.
The council viewed the scale of the proposed development as too large, resembling a new resort altogether. This perspective was a significant factor in the decision to refuse the application, as it was not in line with the character of the existing site.
The refusal to grant planning permission underscores the challenges in balancing development with environmental and community interests. It highlights the importance of considering the long-term impact of such developments on the local landscape and community.
The decision opens a dialogue on sustainable development and community engagement in shaping the future of local landmarks. Erigmore Leisure Park and its stakeholders now face the task of considering alternative plans that align with both community expectations and environmental considerations.